PSA on what’s happening around me in the YOI fandom

YOI-PSA-2

TL;DR

On the bullying going on in the fandom

  • I do not venture outside of certain small Twitter and Tumblr communities. Hence, anyone claiming to be me (“karice” or “whiteboxgems”), or who is accused of being me, is most certainly NOT me.
  • Please do not accuse them of being me (or tora). I’m not just saying this because it affects the two us negatively. Basically, if you accuse them of being associated with us, you are empowering them to keep attacking you, because it has absolutely no consequences for them.

On my interpretation of the show

  • My personal interpretation of Yuuri and Victor’s relationship is that, whilst they are connected to each other in a romantic way, they do not actually become a couple in the course of the show.
  • I am not alone in this. However, about half of the people I chat with about Yuri!!! on ICE have gone underground, because they were being attacked for holding this interpretation.
  • The show itself, and everything that the creators have said, allows for this interpretation. If you don’t agree with this statement, then you do not actually understand what we have written/said about it.
  • Any comment made about me (or what I’ve said/written about YOI) by someone I am not friends with is, almost without exception, based on a misunderstanding of my views.
  • But my views have no bearing on yours. You are free to interpret the show however you want. I personally haven’t come across ANY interpretations that go against what the creators have said.
  • If you disagree with any of this, then please stay away.

And the above in more detail

Just over a week ago, someone on Twitter informed me that people in other parts of the fandom were using my name to attack other fans. I responded with a PSA that asked all fans to refrain from harassing others, and that’s when I learned of what was going on in parts of the fandom that I do not venture into.

I do not know how to stop this behaviour. I don’t even know the full extent of what is going on, because I don’t interact with the people involved in it. The only thing I can really do is to lay out my position as a YOI fan and translator. Let’s start with the former.

Read more of this post

RL Japanese skaters on Yuri!!! on ICE part 2

Satsuki-Muramoto

Satsuki Muramoto’s photo is from the official website of
the Figure & Speed Skating Association of Thailand

And here’s my second translation from the guidebook. This time, we have former ladies singles skaters Akiko Suzuki and Satsuki Muramoto, who have both continued to be involved in the figure skating world even after they retired from competition in 2013. Suzuki is the skater who joined Kenji Miyamoto as “course lecturer” on this special Yuri!!! on ICE figure skating program back on March 3. And as the above image shows, Muramoto is the model for Phichit’s coach at his home rink in Thailand. Please read on if you want to hear their thoughts on the impact that Yuri!!! on ICE has had on their world. Read more of this post

RL Japanese skaters on Yuri!!! on ICE part 1

ISU Junior Grand Prix of Figure Skating - Ljubljana Day 2

Kazuki Tomono of Japan competes during the Junior Men Free Skating on day two of the ISU Junior Grand Prix of Figure Skating on September 23, 2016 in Ljubljana, Slovenia. (Photo by Joosep Martinson – ISU/ISU via Getty Images)

Well, here’s my first translation from the guidebook. Perhaps unsurprisingly, I chose to start on the real life skaters that Figure Skate Life interviewed: this time, I present the young bloods Ryuju Hino, Kazuki Tomono and Koshiro Shimada!

(NB: You can find full translations of the interviews with Evgenia Medvedeva, Stéphane Lambiel and Deniss Vasiļjevs translated by @soukatsu_ here.)

Read more of this post

Kubo Mitsurou on “love and figure skating”

ANN_Myu-Comi_1

Given what’s been happening to a fellow Yuri!!! on ICE fan, translator and friend on tumblr in the wake of the stage event on April 29, I’ve decided to publish a transcript and translation of something that Kubo Mitsurou said about “love in the figure skating world” on live radio last December.

On December 14, 2016,1 Kubo appeared on All Night Nippon’s Myu~Komi Plus radio, where she regaled hosts Yoshida Hisanori and Ogino Karin with tales from behind-the-scenes of the show and her growing love for the world of figure skating.2 Towards the end of the discussion, she started talking talking about the love ( “ai”「愛」) that permeates that world. Here is the entire two-minute segment of that discussion, along with the transcript and translation that I made.

Read more of this post

That’s what she said?! Kubo Mitsurou on ⚤ romance

Pardon me for putting this post off—I was, shall we say, more than a little distracted by certain figure skating competitions over the last month and a half. But now that Worlds and the World Team Trophy have come and gone, I’ve finally been able to get back to the third of three major misinterpretations that arguably led Yuri!!! on ICE fans to criticise Kubo for leaving mixed messages about what she stood for.

Credit: Jason Brown, aka the inspiration for Leo de la Iglesia ^^;

The issue I address here was actually the first one that I personally witnessed, right from the time it started. The comments in question were tweeted by Kubo towards the end of August 2016, though they were only picked up and translated—often separately—for the Western fandom around November 20.

The August tweets

Since context is especially important in this case, let me first present all four of the relevant tweets. Read more of this post

Kato Taihei on doing play-by-plays for Yuri!!! on ICE

SPOTTED!

The “Bento Announcer”!?, Katō Taihei, and the show that has left the Queen speechless!

Katō Taihei (TV Asahi Announcer), who plays announcer Morooka Hisashi

T/N: During his college days, Katō—not to be confused with the skier with a similar name (different kanji)—was known for his aggressive and dynamic plays as a forward in the Waseda University soccer team, the Inaho Kickers. Following graduation, he has worked on the announcing team at TV Asahi. He’s known as the “Bento Announcer” amongst fans because he often tweets about the boxed lunches he eats in the course of his work. This interview was part of the “Sports News!” broadsheet that came with the January 2017 issue of Newtype.

Meet the announcer Katō Taihei, who has achieved great success doing live commentary (play-by-play and analysis). The design of the announcer he plays, Morooka, also seems to be based on Katō himself, complete with his cheerful and refreshing personality.

—As we plunge into the Grand Prix Series and watch the performances of the skaters one after another, I suddenly realised that each of them was graced by your voice, in ‘live commentary’ mode.

Katō: The other day, Toyonaga (Toshiyuki)-san took a little playful jab at me, like “It feels you’re the one who has the most lines, don’t you think?” (chuckles). Read more of this post

That’s what she said?! Kubo Mitsurou and the kiss(?)

Today, I’m going to look at what Kubo Mitsurou has said about the scene at the end of episode 7, where Victor had a surprise greeting for Yuuri as he came off the ice after his Cup of China free skate. Well, I’m stepping right into a minefield here, so I might as well just take the plunge:

yuri_kiss

Personally, I believe it was a kiss, for reasons I’ll go into below. That being said, I fully support anyone who believes otherwise, which brings me to my next point.

What I’m really concerned about is the view that “Kubo implied that it was obvious”—especially when this is used to bash fans whose interpretation of Yuuri and Victor’s relationship is not the same as the dominant one. Read more of this post

Kubo Mitsurou on Yuri!!! on ICE: an early interview

yoi_early-promo-image

And here’s my ‘Anime Writing’ post for this week! This interview, from Spoon.2Di vol.18 (published September 30, 2016) is one of the earliest interviews that Kubo Mitsurou did for Yuri!!! on ICE. If I’m not mistaken, it’s her second magazine interview, after the short one in the October edition of Pash!1 In it, Kubo expands on the way all the stars lined up such that, in the summer of 2014, she embarked on a journey to help Director Yamamoto Sayo create the figure skating anime that the latter had long been dreaming about. If you prefer to read the Japanese original for yourself, aliasanonyme has shared the scans here.

This is the full translation of the interview that I discussed in this editorial. As I mentioned there, I originally intended to post it back in January, until frog-kun advised me to write a more in-depth piece about the mistranslations and misinterpretations we found. I only addressed one of them in the editorial, but if you’re curious about the other major mistakes, you can take a look at them here.

But if you’re only interested in what Kubo herself said about Yuri!!! on ICE just before it started its broadcast, you can find it right here, just under the cut.

Read more of this post

That’s what she said?! Kubo Mitsurou and Yuri!!! on ICE

If you’re a member of the hard-core Yuri!!! on ICE fandom, what has happened over the past few weeks can hardly have escaped your attention. On February 7, the March issue of CREA saw Kubo Mitsurou—who’s credited for the original story and the scripts—indicate that Victor and Yuuri can be thought of as “soulmates,” inciting cheers and celebrations in various places around the web. Then on February 10, her comments in Pash! about the rings being akin to items worn by “members of the same circle” created a fair amount of consternation amongst fans who believe Yuuri and Victor to be engaged.

crea_snippet
(Thank you to @3A3T_ for passing me this scan from CREA!)

The fallout was immediate. Some fans started criticising Kubo for again leaving mixed messages over what she really stood for. In response, others pointed out that what she said did not negate “just how much Yuuri and Victor truly love each other,” an interpretation that the show itself amply supports. But the order of the day seems to have been confusion—one person even asked a major YOI translator not to translate what Kubo said about the rings so as “to keep everyone in YOI fandom happy.”

toraonice responded as I would have, Read more of this post

Kenji Miyamoto on skating as the characters of Yuri!!! on ICE

kenjis-room_shimada
Kenji Miyamoto with Japanese junior skater Koshiro Shimada (source)

My plans for blogging and translating have been all over the place these last few weeks. I’ve actually been sitting on an early interview with Kubo Mitsurou, but the editorial that I’m drafting to accompany it is still in the works. The skating songs and Rakugo Shinjuu interview that I highlighted last week are also in various states of progress, and one of them should be finished by early next week. But then I started reading this interview…and got to a point where I couldn’t stop laughing for about a minute. Imagining Yuuri and Yurio as those animals…oh, Kenji-sensei!

In any case, this is the last interview from the “Miracle on ICE” special that came with the Jan 2017 issue of Animage. After I translated Kubo-sensei’s long interview back in December, Toraonice has slowly been working through the rest. If you’ve missed them, you’ll be able to find all the links in the masterpost.

I honestly wish I’d found time to translate this interview back in December. Being a former figure skater himself, Kenji-sensei has always been the one best able to share just how realistic Yuri!!! on ICE has been, and he goes into far more detail here than in any other interview I’ve read so far. The wrap-up posts I’m planning will be dominated by just how much I love this show as a figure skating fan, but I’m tempted to just let Kenji-sensei do all the talking for me! So please enjoy this interview, and let me know what you think of it in the comments!

I skated the choreography as if I were playing the characters themselves.

Read more of this post