Nekomonogatari Black: questions of love?

Sweet dreams...or dark nightmares?

Sweet dreams…or dark nightmares?

A prequel to ‘Tsubasa Cat’ from Bakemonogatari series, Neko Black lays out exactly what happened during that unforgettable, gold-tinted week; the week when Araragi Koyomi fell out of something that was not a first love…

NekoBlack-12 NekoBlack-11
The main draw of Hanekawa…?

Usually, in a Monogatari story, there’s one topic of conversation between Araragi and one of the people he interacts with that catches my attention. In Bake, it was Hitagi in Mayoi Snail and the episode where she gave the stars away; in Nise, it was Kagenui and the choice between Kaiki, Oshino and her own points of view. This quick review is terribly late because I wasn’t quite so interested…possibly because the theme was ‘love’…

How does a person know that he or she is in love? Is it something he/she just knows? Is wanting to touch them love? And what makes a person fall out of love?

NekoBlack-06 NekoBlack-05
It’s to his sisters that Araragi turns for advice about love…

Hanekawa is one of the three heroines in the Monogatari series that fans get behind as their choice for Araragi. And Neko Black is the series that both raises and dashes those hopes. Araragi does say at one stage that he’s actually way beyond being in love with her, to the stage of wanting to die for her. But by the end of the week, he decides never to speak a word of it to Hanekawa, to bury it instead as something that was not a first love that he had fallen out of.

What's wrong with Hanekawa?

What’s wrong with Hanekawa?

Why? What happened that made him seal away those feelings? I think that it was Hanekawa’s attitude towards herself, an attitude of not valuing herself, which had enabled her to convince herself that getting abused by her father was fine and to be expected. To be blunt about it, it disgusted him. Araragi’s nature is to try to help others, but he also understands that sometimes, people have to want to help themselves first. If they don’t, then no one can help them resolve anything. And that’s what Hanekawa’s problem here ultimately was.

TBC, or course.

p.s. two sidenotes:

NekoBlack-10 NekoBlack-09
Oshino and Shinobu continue to steal the show…

but something that continues to amuse me is this:

NekoBlack-02 NekoBlack-08
Naoetsu, where the bulk of the Monogatari series takes place, is definitely close to the sea. Why then, does Araragi say in the drama CD that he’s never seen the sea!?! And why did Hachikuji play along with it!?!

About karice
MAG fan, freelance translator and political scientist-in-training. I also love musicals, travel and figure skating!

4 Responses to Nekomonogatari Black: questions of love?

  1. RG says:

    “The main draw of Hanekawa?”

    Black Hanekawa? If that is the only reason they like the character, than they don’t really like Hanekawa at all imo. That, and people who aren’t keen on her tend to be self-satisfied on the negative aspects without really trying to understand those negative aspects, as you did in your assessment here. It should be interesting if you ever read Nekomonogatari White, where a lot of Oshino and Araragi’s assumptions are given an….alternate viewpoint.


    • karice says:

      Well…your comment shows that you don’t understand how I write.

      E.g. The question mark was there for a reason…

      Also, this was about Neko Black, not Neko White.


  2. Pingback: Nekomonogatari White: Hanekawa and me | HOT CHOCOLATE IN A BOWL

  3. Pingback: Monogatari Series: Kamimashita! | HOT CHOCOLATE IN A BOWL

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: